Is surrender the same as giving up?

No. In this research, surrender meant letting go of the urge to control the experience, not abandoning it or going passive. It was the state of mind most strongly linked to a deep, mystical-type experience, which in turn was tied to lasting positive change afterward.

What is the opposite of surrender in a session?

In this study it was called preoccupation, a mind caught up in worry and unable to settle. A preoccupied state at the start was the strongest predictor of a challenging or distressing experience, more than any personality trait the researchers measured.

Can you make yourself surrender?

Not on command, since surrender is a state and not a switch. But the same research points to conditions that make it easier: feeling settled going in, a setting where you feel safe, and trust in the people around you, rather than walking in guarded and worried.

Immersion

What does it mean to surrender during a session?

Short answer

Surrender means letting go of the urge to control the experience and allowing it to unfold. In psychedelic research, the state of surrender a person carried into a session was the strongest predictor of a deep, mystical-type experience, while a mind stuck on worry was the strongest predictor of a harder, more distressing one.

The research

Russ, S. L., Carhart-Harris, R. L., Maruyama, G., and Elliott, M. S. (2019). Replication and extension of a model predicting response to psilocybin. Psychopharmacology, volume 236, issue 11, pages 3221 to 3230.

Sample 183 people who had taken psilocybin on their own in the past year

Published 2019

Journal Psychopharmacology

Suzanne Russ and colleagues, including Robin Carhart-Harris, gathered detailed reports from 183 people who had taken psilocybin on their own in the past year. It was a retrospective survey, so people described sessions that had already happened. The team built a statistical model to see what best explained how each session went. Two states of mind at the start stood out. A state of surrender, meaning a willingness to let go and stop fighting the experience, was the strongest predictor of a mystical-type experience. A state of preoccupation, meaning a mind stuck on worries and unable to settle, was the strongest predictor of a challenging or distressing experience. The model was strong. It accounted for about 66 percent of the differences between people in their mystical-experience scores, and about 56 percent of the differences on a measure of dread. A trait called absorption, the tendency to get deeply drawn into inner experience, was the next strongest factor in both. The researchers also found that having a mystical-type experience during the session was linked to lasting positive change afterward.

Read the paper

What does this mean for you?

Surrender is not the same as giving up, and it is not going limp. In this research it meant a specific inner move: loosening your grip on how the experience should go, and letting it be what it is. The people who could do that were the ones most likely to have a deep, meaningful session. The people whose minds stayed clenched on worry tended to have a harder time. That fits what a lot of people describe. Fighting the current usually makes it rougher than floating with it.

It is worth being honest about what this study can and cannot show. It was retrospective, which means people were remembering sessions from the past, and memory is not a perfect record. Everyone reported on themselves, and it was people taking psilocybin on their own, not patients in a clinic with a therapist present. And a link between surrender and a better experience does not prove one caused the other. Read this as a strong signal about what tends to matter, not a promise about your next session.

Even with those limits, the direction is useful and it is kind. Surrender is a state, not a personality flaw, and a guarded, worried mind is a normal way to walk into something unknown. You cannot flip surrender on like a switch. What you can do is tend to the things that make it more possible: a settled state going in, a setting where you feel safe, and trust in the people holding the space with you. That is not about doing the session perfectly. It is about arriving in a way that gives letting go a chance.

The takeaway

Surrender means loosening your grip on how the experience should go, not abandoning it or going limp.
A worried, preoccupied mind going in was tied to harder sessions, so noticing your state beforehand matters.
You cannot force surrender, but you can make it more likely with a settled mind, a safe setting, and people you trust.

Terms in this page

Set and setting Grounding Mental readiness

This is the work Asendar™ was built for: helping you notice the state you are carrying into a session, so you can meet it from a place of readiness rather than resistance. If you want a simple read on where your head is today, take your Mental Readiness Score.

Take your Mental Readiness Score

Explore more in the Immersion pillar